A 49-year-old Wisconsin man has pleaded guilty to murdering his girlfriend and two young girls before hiding their bodies beneath blankets in a locked bedroom, bringing a shocking new development in a triple homicide case that sparked an 11-day manhunt.
Virgil G. Thew admitted Monday, November 16, to three counts of first-degree intentional homicide in the deaths of his girlfriend, Elizabeth Ann Kolba, 33, her 12-year-old daughter, Alexandria Taylor, and Alexandria’s 13-year-old cousin, Skyla Sorenson.
The guilty pleas came nearly two years after the victims were discovered inside a home in New Lisbon, a small Wisconsin community about 80 miles northwest of Madison.
The horrifying case began December 30, 2024, when Skyla’s father became concerned because his daughter had not returned home.
Using Snapchat’s location-sharing feature, he determined that her phone was at Thew’s residence and contacted police to request a welfare check.
Officers visited the property but initially found no sign of Thew or the missing girls.
Later that afternoon, authorities received another call from people inside the home who had made a devastating discovery.
Three bodies were found lying on a bed inside a bedroom secured with a deadbolt. Each victim had been fatally shot, and their bodies had been covered with blankets.
According to court documents, relatives told investigators that Thew was the only person who had keys to the locked room.
With the suspected killer nowhere to be found, authorities launched an extensive search involving local law enforcement, the FBI, and the U.S. Marshals Service.
For more than a week, Thew managed to avoid capture.
Investigators later learned that he had traveled through wooded areas after the killings, apparently attempting to stay out of sight.
His time on the run finally ended January 9, 2025, when authorities received a report about a suspicious person sleeping inside a vehicle in nearby Elroy.
Deputies approached the car and identified the occupant as Thew.
When questioned about what he was doing, he offered an unusual explanation, claiming he was attempting a “21-day survival challenge.”
But his explanation did little to change the situation.
Thew was arrested, and during subsequent questioning, he admitted to shooting the three victims, according to the criminal complaint.
He also directed investigators to the location where he had hidden the murder weapon, which authorities later recovered.
Despite his confession, investigators have never publicly established a motive for the killings.
That unanswered question has been especially painful for the victims’ families.
Skyla’s father, Jerry Sorenson, previously pleaded for an explanation from the man responsible for taking his daughter’s life.
“Will you be a man and tell somebody ‘Why?’ Please,” he said during an emotional interview with local television station WKBT.
As the case moved through the court system, Thew initially pleaded not guilty and was scheduled to stand trial in December 2026.
However, during a hearing in Juneau County Circuit Court on November 16, he changed his plea and admitted responsibility for all three murders.
As part of the plea agreement, prosecutors dismissed several additional charges, including three counts of hiding a corpse, possession of a firearm by a convicted felon, vehicle theft, and resisting or obstructing an officer.
Those allegations may still be considered by the judge during sentencing.
For the families, the guilty pleas provide a measure of accountability, but they cannot undo the devastating loss of three lives.
Kolba, affectionately known as Beth, was remembered as a joyful woman who loved the outdoors and working on the family farm.
Her obituary described her enthusiasm for operating tractors, grain carts, and combines, along with the happiness she found spending time with friends and family.
Her daughter Alexandria was an energetic young athlete who had developed a passion for wrestling.
Loved ones remembered her determination and larger-than-life personality, describing a girl who seemed destined for great things.
“Alexandria came into this world with a purpose,” her family wrote in her obituary.
Skyla, meanwhile, was remembered for her love of animals, especially cows, and her appreciation for the simple pleasures of country life.
She enjoyed reading, crafting colorful rubber-band bracelets, and spending time around farms.
The deaths of the three victims devastated their families and the close-knit New Lisbon community, where residents had followed the investigation and subsequent manhunt with growing concern.
Thew is now scheduled to be sentenced December 4 by Juneau County Circuit Judge Paul Curran.
Under Wisconsin law, first-degree intentional homicide carries a mandatory life sentence. The judge will determine whether Thew will ever be eligible to apply for extended supervision.
His guilty pleas mean the case will not proceed to the jury trial originally scheduled for December.

