A Pennsylvania woman who suspected someone was secretly tampering with her coffee mug made a horrifying discovery that ultimately led to her manager’s arrest. Now, the man responsible is heading to jail after admitting to stalking her in a disturbing workplace scandal.
Timothy Haver, 45, a former manager at Highmark Health in Pittsburgh, was sentenced Tuesday, November 17, to one to two years in county jail after pleading guilty to misdemeanor stalking.
The sentence comes nearly a year after investigators uncovered allegations that Haver had repeatedly contaminated a female co-worker’s drinking mug with bodily fluids, claiming it was the only way he could get close to her.
The ordeal began in October 2025, when the woman, whose identity has been withheld, started noticing something strange about her insulated coffee mug.
According to court documents, she had filled the container with water while working at the office but noticed that it tasted unusual when she took a drink.
Days later, she discovered a suspicious substance at the bottom of the mug.
Concerned about what she had found, she showed it to another person, who agreed that the substance appeared to be semen.
The discovery was disturbing enough, but it wasn’t an isolated incident.
The woman had also reported experiencing anonymous harassment and believed someone might be stalking her at work.
As her suspicions grew, she contacted Highmark Health’s security department, which began investigating the situation.
With her permission, investigators installed a hidden camera inside her office to determine who might be tampering with her belongings.
What the footage revealed was deeply unsettling.
According to police, the camera captured Haver entering the woman’s workspace, removing her mug from her desk and returning it later.
Investigators documented two separate occasions when he handled the container. After each incident, the woman discovered another suspicious substance inside.
Security personnel collected samples from the mug and preserved them as evidence.
On November 20, 2025, the woman again reported finding an unknown substance in her cup, leading investigators to collect additional evidence.
By then, police had gathered enough information to confront Haver.
During questioning, the manager admitted to tampering with the woman’s mug and offered investigators a bizarre explanation.
According to the criminal complaint, Haver said he “felt this was the only way to get close to her.”
The admission stunned those investigating the case, particularly because the woman had been unknowingly exposed to the contamination while simply trying to drink from her own cup at work.
Haver was fired from Highmark Health on November 20, 2025, and subsequently faced criminal charges, including stalking, six counts of indecent assault and harassment.
The case moved through the court system for nearly a year before reaching a resolution this week.
Under a plea agreement negotiated with Allegheny County prosecutors, Haver admitted guilt to misdemeanor stalking in exchange for the dismissal of the remaining charges.
His attorney, Casey White, confirmed that the agreement also eliminated the possibility that Haver would be required to register as a sex offender under Pennsylvania’s Megan’s Law.
White said his client was remorseful and had accepted responsibility for his conduct.
However, the resolution brought mixed emotions for the woman at the center of the case.
Speaking to WPXI after the hearing, she said she felt relieved that Haver would spend time behind bars but was disappointed that he would not be required to register as a sex offender.
During her victim impact statement, she described the experience as “the worst year of my life.”
She explained that the repeated violations had left her struggling with post-traumatic stress disorder and feeling anxious about something as ordinary as accepting a cup of coffee from another person.
The psychological impact has followed her long after Haver was removed from the workplace.
Her husband also addressed Haver during the proceedings, delivering a brief but pointed message.
“You are a criminal,” he told the former manager.
The case has attracted widespread attention because the misconduct allegedly continued for weeks inside a professional workplace, where the victim had no reason to believe her personal belongings were being secretly targeted.
For the woman, the hidden camera ultimately provided the answers she had been desperately seeking, revealing that the person responsible was someone she worked alongside.
Haver has now been sentenced to one to two years in jail, bringing the criminal case to a close.
But while the former manager faces the consequences of his actions, the woman he targeted says the ordeal has permanently changed how safe she feels in everyday situations, even when performing something as simple as drinking from a coffee mug.

