A 49-year-old Wisconsin man has pleaded guilty to murdering his girlfriend and two young girls whose bodies were discovered beneath blankets inside a locked bedroom, bringing a major development in a disturbing triple homicide case that sparked a lengthy manhunt.
Virgil Thew entered guilty pleas to three counts of first-degree intentional homicide on Monday, November 16, nearly two years after the deaths of Elizabeth Kolba, 33, Alexandria Taylor, 12, and Skyla Sorenson, 13, in New Lisbon, Wisconsin.
The victims were discovered December 30, 2024, inside a bedroom at the home Thew shared with his mother. All three had suffered fatal gunshot wounds, and investigators determined that Thew had fled the area.
The case began when Skyla’s father became concerned after his daughter failed to return home the previous night.
According to court documents, he checked her location using Snapchat and discovered that her phone appeared to be at Thew’s residence, prompting him to contact police and request a welfare check.
Officers initially visited the property but were unable to locate Thew or the missing girls.
Hours later, around 4 p.m., people inside the home made a horrifying discovery.
The three victims were found together on a bed in a bedroom secured with a deadbolt. Their bodies had been covered with blankets.
Investigators learned that Thew was the only person believed to have keys to the locked room, making him a central focus of the investigation.
By then, however, he had disappeared.
Police launched an extensive search for Thew, who investigators later determined had traveled through wooded areas in an attempt to avoid being captured.
Authorities say he eventually stole a vehicle after finding the keys inside.
His time on the run ended January 9, 2025, when deputies discovered him sleeping inside the stolen car in Elroy, a small community not far from New Lisbon.
When an officer approached and questioned him about what he was doing, Thew offered an unusual explanation.
According to the criminal complaint, he claimed he was attempting a “21-day survival challenge.”
But investigators soon learned that his disappearance was connected to something far more serious.
During questioning, Thew admitted that he remembered shooting all three victims and identified the firearm used in the killings, according to court records.
He also directed detectives to the location where he had hidden the weapon, which investigators subsequently recovered.
Despite his admissions, authorities have not publicly established a motive for the murders.
The victims’ deaths devastated their families and the close-knit New Lisbon community.
Kolba was remembered as a loving mother who enjoyed spending time outdoors and working on the family farm. Her obituary described her as a joyful woman who loved her friends and relatives and took pride in operating tractors and other farm equipment.
Her daughter, Alexandria, was an enthusiastic young wrestler whose determination and outgoing personality left a lasting impression on those who knew her.
Family members described her as a girl with an extraordinary spirit and a bright future ahead of her.
Skyla, Alexandria’s cousin, was remembered for her love of country life, animals, reading, and making colorful bracelets.
For Skyla’s father, the tragedy has been made even more painful by the absence of an explanation.
In an earlier interview with local television station WKBT, Jerry Sorenson publicly pleaded with Thew to reveal why he killed the three victims.
“Will you be a man and tell somebody ‘Why?’ Please,” Sorenson said.
Thew initially pleaded not guilty and was scheduled to stand trial in December 2026.
However, during Monday’s hearing in Juneau County Circuit Court, he changed his plea and admitted responsibility for all three murders.
His guilty pleas eliminate the need for a jury trial and move the case directly toward sentencing.
Thew is scheduled to appear before a judge December 4, when he will learn how much of the rest of his life he will spend behind bars.
Under Wisconsin law, first-degree intentional homicide carries a mandatory life sentence, with the judge determining whether a defendant will ever be eligible to seek extended supervision.
For the families of Elizabeth, Alexandria, and Skyla, the guilty pleas provide a measure of accountability after nearly two years of grief and uncertainty.
But one question remains unanswered: why Thew killed his girlfriend and the two girls before concealing their bodies and fleeing into the Wisconsin countryside.

