A Florida man is facing serious criminal charges after allegedly mailing a peanut butter-covered greeting card to his ex-wife’s best friend, knowing that even a small amount of the substance could trigger a potentially deadly allergic reaction.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, of Plantation, was arrested Friday, November 13, following a lengthy police investigation into what authorities believe was a calculated act of revenge stemming from his bitter divorce.
Investigators say Cancellare deliberately targeted a woman he had known for more than 20 years, allegedly using her severe peanut allergy against her because he blamed her for the breakdown of his marriage.
The frightening encounter began on August 14, 2025, when the woman returned home from work and discovered a mysterious blue envelope among her mail.
According to a probable cause affidavit, the envelope appeared unusually greasy and featured unfamiliar handwriting. It was addressed to someone named “Goergina Sawals,” a name investigators later determined was fictitious.
When the woman opened the envelope, she discovered a greeting card containing a brown substance spread across its interior.
She immediately recognized it as peanut butter.
Knowing that exposure could be life-threatening, she dropped the envelope, rushed inside and washed her hands. But despite her quick reaction, she soon developed hives on both arms and experienced a tingling sensation that lasted approximately six hours.
The woman told police she has an extremely severe peanut allergy that requires her to avoid not only peanuts themselves but also peanut oil and food that may have come into contact with peanut products.
She explained that exposure could interfere with her breathing and potentially cause a fatal allergic reaction without immediate medical treatment.
What initially appeared to be a strange and disturbing piece of mail soon developed into a criminal investigation.
Plantation police contacted the U.S. Postal Service, and investigators discovered that the two Forever stamps attached to the envelope had been purchased from a self-service kiosk at a post office in Davie, Florida, on August 8, 2025.
The stamps contained identifying codes that allowed authorities to trace the exact transaction. According to police, the purchase was made using a Visa credit card belonging to Cancellare.
But investigators uncovered another important clue.
The postal kiosk had photographed the person purchasing the stamps.
When detectives showed the image to the woman, she immediately identified the man as Cancellare, her best friend’s former husband. Other people familiar with him also reportedly recognized him in the photograph.
Investigators determined that the envelope had been processed through a Miami postal facility on August 13, just one day before the woman received it.
Police believe Cancellare attempted to conceal his involvement by using a false sender name and return address. He also allegedly wore sunglasses inside the post office and traveled to a different city to mail the card.
As detectives examined the relationship between the suspect and the victim, they uncovered a possible motive.
The woman told investigators that she and Cancellare had known each other for approximately two decades and frequently socialized together while he was married to her best friend.
During dinners and other gatherings, she regularly warned restaurant employees about her allergy and took extensive precautions to avoid accidental exposure.
According to investigators, Cancellare witnessed these precautions repeatedly and understood how dangerous peanuts could be for her.
The relationship reportedly deteriorated during his contentious divorce.
Police said Cancellare blamed the woman for the collapse of his marriage, and she had previously served as an observer during the division of property between the former couple in July 2022.
That was reportedly the last time she had seen him before the suspicious envelope arrived.
The investigation also revealed troubling allegations from another acquaintance, who told police that Cancellare had made comments expressing a desire to harm people connected to the divorce.
Authorities believe the greeting card was not a harmless prank but an intentional attempt to expose the woman to a substance that could seriously injure or kill her.
In their arrest affidavit, investigators described the woman’s immediate reaction as an effort to protect her life and said the experience had caused lasting emotional distress.
The investigation continued for more than a year as detectives gathered witness statements, postal records and medical documentation concerning the woman’s allergy.
On November 13, 2026, officers arrested Cancellare at his Plantation home. He was taken for medical clearance before being transported to the Broward County Jail.
He was charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence exposing another person to harm.
The aggravated battery charge reflects prosecutors’ allegation that the peanut butter was deliberately used as a dangerous weapon against someone with a known life-threatening allergy.
Cancellare’s bond was initially set at $20,000, and subsequent reporting indicated that he had been released after posting bond. His next court appearance had not been publicly listed.
It remains unclear whether he has entered a plea or retained an attorney. The allegations have not been proven in court.
For investigators, the case illustrates how an ordinary household food can become dangerous when deliberately used against someone with a severe allergy.

