A 66-year-old Australian woman has been found guilty of murdering both of her elderly parents after secretly injecting them with fatal doses of insulin more than a year apart. But it was what she said when she believed nobody was listening that helped expose the horrifying truth.

Raelene Polymiadis was convicted Friday, November 20, of killing her mother, Brenda Anderson, and father, Lynton Anderson, who were both 94 when they died.

The verdicts followed a lengthy trial in the South Australian Supreme Court, where jurors heard disturbing recordings of Polymiadis apparently confessing to God while alone in her car.

“Please, Lord, you know, yes, I have sinned. I have. Thou shalt not kill,” she said in one recording secretly captured by police.

Then came an even more revealing admission.

“I have sinned twice in my life, and I hate it,” she continued, before referring to her parents’ wishes to avoid being placed in a nursing home.

Prosecutors argued that those words were evidence of her responsibility for the two killings, which occurred approximately 14 months apart.

Polymiadis, who has Type 1 diabetes, had access to insulin as part of her own medical treatment. According to prosecutors, she used that same medication to kill her parents, neither of whom was diabetic.

The first victim was her mother, Brenda, who had been hospitalized following a fall in March 2022.

During her hospital stay, prosecutors said, Polymiadis administered insulin to her mother on two separate occasions. Brenda subsequently died.

At the time, her death did not immediately lead to murder charges.

But just over a year later, another suspicious death would bring the family under intense scrutiny.

On April 30, 2023, a caregiver found Lynton Anderson unconscious inside his home, approximately two hours after his daughter had visited.

He was rushed for medical treatment but died the following day.

Medical evidence revealed that he had suffered fatal insulin toxicity, prompting investigators to take a closer look at both parents’ deaths.

As detectives began examining Polymiadis’s movements and access to insulin, they uncovered a family disagreement that prosecutors suggested may have played a role in the killings.

Both elderly parents had reportedly expressed strong opposition to moving into residential nursing care.

Polymiadis’s brother, Graham Anderson, testified that he and his sister had argued about whether their father should enter a care facility just five days before his death.

During a police interview, Polymiadis suggested her father had been deeply upset by the prospect of leaving his home.

“If you want a cause of death for dad, try a broken heart,” she told detectives.

But investigators were gathering evidence that pointed toward something far more sinister.

After interviewing Polymiadis in June 2023, police secretly recorded conversations and prayers inside her vehicle.

The recordings captured her repeatedly asking God for forgiveness and referring to sins involving both parents.

In another recording played during the trial, she described what she had done as a mortal sin and suggested she had wanted to spare her parents from suffering.

Prosecutors portrayed those remarks as devastating evidence that she knew exactly what had happened.

Investigators also discovered handwritten notes that appeared to outline how Polymiadis should respond to police questioning.

One note suggested investigators might wait to see whether she became overconfident and said something incriminating.

The jury also heard testimony from a former boyfriend who claimed Polymiadis had once described insulin as an ideal murder weapon because it occurs naturally in the human body and could be difficult to detect.

Her defense attorneys disputed the prosecution’s interpretation of the evidence.

They argued that the secret prayers were not admissions of murder but expressions of guilt and personal responsibility over her parents’ deaths.

The defense also suggested that her mother could have died from a stress-related heart condition and that her father may have taken his own life using insulin to which he had access.

However, after hearing months of testimony, the jury rejected those explanations.

Following a trial that lasted more than five months, jurors deliberated for less than a day before returning unanimous guilty verdicts on both murder charges.

Polymiadis appeared visibly shaken as the verdicts were announced.

She gripped the dock as the first guilty verdict was read aloud, then wiped tears from her eyes after hearing the second.

The 66-year-old repeatedly shook her head as the reality of the convictions became clear.

Her bail was immediately revoked, and she was taken into custody.

Under South Australian law, murder carries a mandatory life sentence, meaning Polymiadis now faces life imprisonment for each of her parents’ deaths. The court will determine the terms of her punishment during the sentencing process.

She is scheduled to return to court December 16 for a directions hearing.

The case has shocked Australia, not only because of the ages of the victims but also because their own daughter was found responsible for killing them while they were facing difficult decisions about their future care.

For nearly five years after Brenda’s death, the circumstances surrounding the family’s tragedies remained the subject of a complicated criminal investigation and court proceedings.

Leave a Reply