A Washington, D.C., mother who rushed downstairs to break up a fight between her teenage twin sons watched her worst nightmare unfold when one brother allegedly shot the other during an argument over personal belongings.
Now, 16-year-old Jamari Young is facing a second-degree murder charge in the death of his identical twin brother, Jabrell Young, despite their mother’s insistence that the shooting was a tragic accident.
The heartbreaking incident occurred on the morning of October 25 inside the family’s home in Northeast Washington.
According to court documents, the boys had been arguing about someone entering a bedroom and touching personal belongings when the confrontation turned physical.
Their mother, Chantel Poe, was asleep upstairs when she heard yelling coming from the basement, where both teenagers had bedrooms.
One of the boys could reportedly be heard shouting, “Stop touching my stuff,” while another voice insisted that he didn’t have the missing belongings.
Concerned that the argument was escalating, Poe hurried downstairs and discovered her sons wrestling outside their bedrooms.
She immediately stepped between them, desperately trying to separate the teenagers.
But moments later, a gun went off.
According to the police affidavit, Poe turned around and saw Jamari holding a firearm. When she looked back toward Jabrell, he had collapsed to the floor.
The wounded teenager had been shot twice in the chest.
What happened next was especially heartbreaking.
Jamari allegedly began apologizing repeatedly, telling his mother that he hadn’t intended to shoot his brother.
“I didn’t mean to! It just went off! I didn’t mean to! I’m sorry, Ma!” he reportedly cried.
Poe, who had just witnessed one of her sons collapse, screamed at Jamari in disbelief.
“You just shot my son!” she reportedly shouted before ordering him to leave the house.
Emergency services were called, and officers from the Metropolitan Police Department arrived at the residence in the 200 block of 46th Street Northeast around 8:30 a.m.
They discovered Jabrell lying in his mother’s lap, unconscious and not breathing.
Despite efforts by emergency personnel to save him, the teenager was pronounced dead at the scene.
By the time officers arrived, Jamari had left.
Investigators reviewed neighborhood surveillance footage that reportedly showed the teenager leaving the property, initially walking before breaking into a run as police sirens approached.
Detectives also recovered ammunition and shell casings while examining the home.
In a separate development, police discovered a loaded handgun that another person had allegedly concealed inside a blanket beneath a vehicle outside the residence.
Investigators later linked that firearm to an unrelated shooting in Washington earlier in the year, although authorities have not established whether it was the weapon used to kill Jabrell.
As police continued investigating, Poe maintained that her surviving son had never intended to hurt his brother.
She described the twins as inseparable, telling investigators they were “thick as thieves.”
According to their mother, the boys had grown up as best friends, sharing a bond that made the idea of one deliberately killing the other almost impossible for her to accept.
Following Jamari’s arrest on November 18, Poe spoke emotionally outside the courthouse, defending her son against the murder allegation.
“This is an accident! This is an accident!” she told reporters.
She insisted that the shooting was not malicious and said Jamari had fled because he was frightened.
“My son and his brother are best friends. They love each other,” she said.
Despite her account, prosecutors argued that the circumstances supported a murder charge.
The medical examiner determined that Jabrell died from two gunshot wounds to the chest and classified his death as a homicide.
During Jamari’s initial court appearance, prosecutors emphasized that the gun had fired twice, raising questions about whether the shooting could be considered entirely accidental.
However, the judge acknowledged an important distinction.
Magistrate Judge Dorsey Jones said he did not believe Jamari had necessarily intended to kill his brother, but concluded there was sufficient evidence to support the second-degree murder charge.
Under the law, a killing can qualify as second-degree murder even without proof that the accused specifically intended the victim’s death, depending on the circumstances and the level of disregard for human life.
Jamari, who is being prosecuted as an adult despite being just 16, was ordered held without bond.
His next court appearance is scheduled for December 7.
The case has devastated a family already struggling with the loss of one child while facing the possibility that another could spend years behind bars.
For Poe, the tragedy is especially painful because she was standing between her sons, trying to stop what appeared to be an ordinary sibling argument, when the gun discharged.
Now, investigators and prosecutors must determine whether Jamari’s actions amounted to criminally reckless violence or whether the shooting occurred in the accidental manner his mother describes.


Why are blacks so dysfunctional? What kind of a moron parent allows her 16 year-old to own a gun?