A New York jury has convicted a Long Island man of first-degree murder after prosecutors said he subjected his longtime friend to a six-hour ordeal of torture that ended in his death.

Jeremy Allen, 44, of East Quogue near the Hamptons, was found guilty of murdering 43-year-old Christopher Hahn, a friend he had known since high school. Prosecutors said Allen beat Hahn, suffocated him with a plastic bag, and ultimately stabbed him in the neck while watching him slowly die inside his blood-soaked home.

According to the Suffolk County District Attorney’s Office, the two men had spent the evening drinking together at a bar before returning to Allen’s home shortly after midnight on September 27, 2024. What happened next unfolded over hours and was partially captured by Allen’s own surveillance system.

Prosecutors said audio from exterior security cameras recorded the first 18 minutes of the attack, during which Allen brutally beat Hahn. Footage later showed Allen dragging Hahn, described as bruised and semi-conscious, onto the back deck of the house.

At one point, Allen left Hahn lying outside before returning with a baseball bat, which he used to repeatedly strike Hahn’s head and body. Authorities said Allen knew his friend was still alive and in visible distress during the beating.

Surveillance video then showed Allen placing a plastic bag over Hahn’s head. Prosecutors said Allen sat nearby in a lawn chair and watched as Hahn suffocated for approximately eight minutes.

The attack ended when Allen stabbed Hahn in the neck with what prosecutors described as a large knife.

“He stood over the victim and watched as he took his last breaths,” the district attorney’s office said.

After Hahn was dead, prosecutors said Allen attempted to enlist his handyman to help deal with the scene. When the handyman arrived, he found blood throughout the home and Hahn’s body covered with a blanket. Allen allegedly told the man he could not leave because he had witnessed the aftermath of the killing.

The handyman eventually persuaded Allen to let him go and immediately called 911. Police arrested Allen at his home soon afterward.

In a statement following the verdict, Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond A. Tierney said Allen’s actions represented a shocking betrayal.

“He betrayed a bond of friendship in the most horrific way imaginable, and today’s verdict holds him accountable,” Tierney said. “The evidence presented at trial demonstrated the deliberate cruelty of his actions over the course of several hours.”

Allen’s defense attorney, Colin Astarita, did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Prosecutors have not identified a motive for the killing.

Allen was also convicted of tampering with physical evidence and now faces a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.

2 thoughts on “Man Tortures Childhood Friend for Hours, Watches Him Die in Brutal Murder Case”
  1. The wackiest people in America are found on Long Island.
    Let me guess, this pos already has his obligatory bad boy beard… he no doubt has his ball cap and drives his jacked up black pickup, with black tinted windows, like a moron weaving in and out traffic on the LIE while tailgating everyone he can.

Leave a Reply