A former Long Island high school art teacher accused in a lawsuit of raping one of his students inside his classroom has now been arrested for allegedly stalking the same young woman.
John Kennedy, 53, was taken into custody Thursday evening at his home in St. James after the former Bay Shore High School student called 911 and reported that he was following her, according to Suffolk County police.
The alleged victim, who is now 18, told authorities she spotted Kennedy trailing her after she left her Bay Shore home and traveled to an undisclosed location in Selden on Thursday morning.
“Suffolk County Police today arrested a high school teacher for stalking a former student that he had sexual affairs with previously,” a police spokesperson said.
Kennedy’s arrest comes just over a week after the woman filed a lawsuit against the Bay Shore school district accusing administrators of failing to protect her from what the complaint describes as a “serial sexual predator.”
According to the lawsuit, Kennedy allegedly groomed and repeatedly raped the student inside his own classroom while she was a senior in his art class.
The allegations first became public last year after Kennedy was placed on administrative leave over claims that he had been having sex with the then-17-year-old student.
Kennedy had reportedly been considered a favorite teacher by many current and former students before the allegations surfaced.
Because the student was 17 at the time, she was above New York’s legal age of consent. Suffolk County police initially closed a criminal investigation after saying they did not find evidence of criminal conduct.
However, the woman’s attorney, Andrew Silvershein, has argued that Kennedy’s position as her teacher created a clear power imbalance and made the relationship exploitative regardless of the age-of-consent law.
The lawsuit also alleges that Bay Shore school officials ignored warning signs and failed in their responsibility to protect the student from grooming and abuse.
Bay Shore Superintendent Steven Maloney has pushed back against those claims, saying the district acted quickly once administrators learned about the allegations.
Maloney said Kennedy was immediately placed on administrative leave, barred from school property and reported to Suffolk County police.
Kennedy is no longer teaching at Bay Shore High School.
The latest arrest adds another troubling chapter to a district that has already faced several high-profile sexual misconduct cases involving school employees.
In November 2024, the district was ordered to pay $25 million in damages in a case involving retired third-grade teacher Thomas Bernagozzi.
Bernagozzi was accused of sexually abusing students for more than 30 years, with alleged misconduct dating from the 1970s through the early 2000s.
A Suffolk County jury found that the district had ignored repeated warning signs, and more than 50 former students have since come forward with allegations involving Bernagozzi.
In another case, Bay Shore High School teacher’s assistant Marcus Johnson was charged with raping a 15-year-old student in 2017.
Kennedy’s latest case remains under investigation.
A working phone number for Kennedy could not immediately be located, and it was not clear whether he had retained an attorney in connection with the stalking charge.


He is so gross, yuck!!!