A 69-year-old Oklahoma mother was killed after confronting her son about a car he had borrowed and refused to return, with police saying he suddenly threw the vehicle into reverse and pinned her between two cars.
Now, more than a month after the horrifying confrontation, 31-year-old John Tiffin is behind bars on a second-degree murder charge following a dramatic arrest in which officers say they found him hiding in a bedroom with two knives.
The tragedy unfolded on October 8 outside a home near East 38th Street and South Mingo Road in Tulsa, where Karen Curthoys had gone with another son to retrieve her missing vehicle.
According to investigators, Tiffin had borrowed his mother’s car weeks earlier with the understanding that he would eventually bring it back. But when he failed to return it, Karen decided to track it down herself.
In an unusual twist, the family reportedly located the vehicle using an Apple AirTag attached to the collar of Karen’s dog, which had been staying with Tiffin.
Karen and her other son, Timothy, drove to the property, where they discovered the borrowed car parked in the driveway.
What should have been a simple attempt to recover her property quickly turned into a deadly confrontation.
Police say Karen was standing between the vehicle she had arrived in and the car Tiffin had borrowed when Timothy approached the driver’s side and opened a door to confront his brother.
Tiffin and his boyfriend were reportedly sitting inside the vehicle when an argument erupted.
Moments later, investigators allege Tiffin shifted the car into reverse and slammed on the accelerator.
The open door struck his brother, while Karen was trapped between the two vehicles.
Emergency crews rushed to the scene around 8:45 p.m. and transported the critically injured mother to a nearby hospital.
Despite receiving medical treatment, Karen died from her injuries on October 12, four days after the confrontation.
Tiffin was initially questioned by police and released while homicide detectives continued investigating the circumstances surrounding his mother’s death.
But as investigators gathered additional evidence, authorities determined there was enough probable cause to pursue a murder charge.
On November 10, a judge authorized an arrest warrant, setting the stage for another disturbing encounter.
That evening, officers with the Tulsa Police Department’s Fugitive Warrants Unit arrived at the residence where Tiffin was believed to be staying.
When he refused repeated orders to come outside, police entered the home with the assistance of a K-9 unit.
Officers eventually located Tiffin hiding in a bedroom, where they say he was holding two knives and attempting to injure his own neck.
After several commands, he dropped the weapons and surrendered.
Police transported him to a hospital for medical evaluation before booking him into the Tulsa County Jail.
He now faces second-degree murder, assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, reckless driving and obstructing an officer.
His bond was reportedly set at $550,500.
The devastating case has also brought renewed attention to the woman at the center of the tragedy.
Karen was remembered in her obituary as a devoted mother who loved cheering on her sons at sporting events and supporting the local arts community.
She was an enthusiastic traveler who particularly enjoyed visiting Belize, where she spent time scuba diving along the country’s famous barrier reef.
Friends and relatives also remembered her love of football, basketball and baseball, as well as her involvement with the Tulsa Opera.
For a family now mourning her death, the circumstances are particularly difficult to comprehend. What began as a mother’s effort to retrieve a borrowed car ended with her losing her life and another son facing a murder prosecution.
Investigators have not publicly established whether Tiffin intended to strike his mother or why the confrontation escalated so suddenly.

