A Florida plastic surgeon who murdered an attorney inside his law firm’s bathroom before disposing of his body in a remote dumpster near the Everglades has been sentenced to death, bringing a dramatic conclusion to a case that baffled investigators for more than three years.

Dr. Tomasz Kosowski, 47, learned his fate Friday, November 20, after a judge determined that the killing of 41-year-old attorney Steven Cozzi was so carefully planned that the death penalty was warranted.

The disturbing case attracted national attention because Cozzi’s body was never recovered, even after investigators traced the surgeon’s movements across Florida and uncovered extensive forensic evidence linking him to the murder.

Kosowski had also made the unusual decision to represent himself during his criminal trial, insisting that prosecutors could not prove he had committed the killing.

But the judge disagreed.

The case began on March 21, 2023, when Cozzi disappeared from his workplace at Blanchard Law in Largo, Florida, just outside Tampa.

His sudden disappearance immediately raised concerns among colleagues.

Cozzi’s wallet, cellphone and keys were still sitting on his desk, and an unfinished work document remained open on his computer.

There was no indication that he had planned to leave.

His husband, Michael Montgomery, also became alarmed when Cozzi failed to return home or respond to calls.

As investigators examined the law office, they discovered something deeply troubling.

Blood and other forensic evidence were found inside a bathroom, suggesting that Cozzi had been attacked before he could leave the building.

Detectives soon focused on Kosowski, a plastic surgeon who had been involved in a bitter legal dispute with a medical practice represented by Cozzi.

The surgeon had accused his former employer of withholding thousands of dollars in medical billings and damaging his professional reputation.

According to prosecutors, Kosowski became increasingly consumed by the lawsuit and ultimately developed a plan to eliminate an attorney representing the opposing parties.

On the morning Cozzi disappeared, the two men participated in a telephone conference about the ongoing litigation.

Investigators later determined that Kosowski had joined the call while sitting inside a Toyota pickup truck parked outside the law firm.

Prosecutors argued that he had arrived prepared to commit murder.

Among the items they said he brought were garbage bags, a syringe containing a powerful paralyzing medication and equipment capable of transporting a body.

Shortly after the conference call, Cozzi vanished.

Investigators used surveillance footage, cellphone records and forensic evidence to reconstruct Kosowski’s movements.

They determined that the surgeon had traveled from the Tampa Bay area to a remote location along the Tamiami Trail, a highway running through the Everglades west of Miami.

Authorities believe he placed Cozzi’s body inside a commercial dumpster, which was later emptied by a garbage truck.

One particularly disturbing piece of evidence came from the truck driver, who recalled an unusually foul odor coming from that collection stop.

Investigators traced the garbage route to a landfill in Collier County and launched an extensive search.

However, the facility routinely compressed large amounts of waste, making it nearly impossible to locate the remains.

Cozzi’s body was never found.

Despite that obstacle, detectives continued building their case.

Forensic testing revealed Cozzi’s blood and DNA inside the law office bathroom and in the garage of Kosowski’s home in Tarpon Springs.

Investigators also recovered the surgeon’s fingerprint from an area of the law firm that was not generally accessible to visitors.

When authorities arrested Kosowski, they discovered a startling collection of items, including approximately $280,000 in cash, masks, duct tape, firearms, a ballistic vest marked “EMS” and law enforcement patches.

They also recovered a vial of succinylcholine, a medication capable of temporarily paralyzing muscles.

A separate search of his residence uncovered roughly 200 firearms, according to court documents.

Prosecutors argued that the evidence demonstrated a deliberate, calculated effort to murder Cozzi and conceal what had happened.

Kosowski was charged with first-degree murder, but his trial took an unusual turn when he decided to defend himself.

He waived his right to a jury, leaving Pinellas County Circuit Judge Joseph Bulone to determine whether the evidence established his guilt.

During the proceedings, Kosowski argued that prosecutors had failed to prove their case because investigators never recovered Cozzi’s body.

He also questioned whether he could have physically moved the attorney, who weighed approximately 190 pounds, into his truck.

However, the judge rejected those arguments.

On September 23, 2026, Bulone found Kosowski guilty of first-degree murder.

The case then moved into the penalty phase, where the court had to decide whether he would receive life imprisonment without parole or a death sentence.

Kosowski declined to present evidence asking the court for mercy.

However, a court-appointed attorney highlighted several mitigating factors, including his lack of a prior criminal record, medical education and professional work as a reconstructive surgeon.

Those considerations ultimately failed to persuade the judge.

During Friday’s sentencing hearing, Bulone concluded that the murder had been carried out in a cold, calculated and premeditated manner.

He also determined that financial gain was an aggravating factor.

“The court concludes that the defendant, under the laws of the State of Florida, has forfeited his right to live,” Bulone said.

Kosowski was then formally sentenced to death.

The judge appointed the public defender’s office to represent him during the appeals process, which could continue for years.

For Cozzi’s family, the sentence marks a significant legal milestone after more than three years of grief and uncertainty.

But one painful question remains unanswered.

Despite the murder conviction, the extensive investigation and the death sentence, Cozzi’s remains have never been located.

His loved ones have been left without the opportunity to recover his body or lay him to rest.

One thought on “Plastic Surgeon Gets Death Penalty for Murdering Rival Lawyer”

Leave a Reply